About
About Our Insurance Agency
We believe that a knowledgeable team of qualified insurance professionals, excellent customer service and access to the best insurance carriers is the only way to achieve the high level of protection you desire. Schumacher Insurance Agency is about finding the right protection to fit your specific needs.
Service With Integrity
Our commitment to excellence means you will always receive quick, courteous and knowledgeable service. Schumacher Insurance Agency seeks to be your valued partner in your success by managing and insuring risk from your enterprise.
Providing the Highest Level of Benefit for the Lowest Price
Schumacher Insurance Agency was created in 1978 and maintains decades of combined experience in the insurance industry. We continue to share the common goal of developing a hands-on business where we can personally understand and respond to the needs of our clients. We feel it is important to guarantee each client superior service.
Today we are recognized as one of the leading client-oriented and independently owned agencies in New Jersey. Schumacher Insurance Agency is dedicated to providing you with the best risk management services available at the most competitive premiums.
We Pride Ourselves in Being Innovative
We pride ourselves in being innovative by actively exploring various ways to reduce your business risks, as well as expenses. Each client’s business or personal situation is reviewed in order to address potential risk and insurance cost. It is vital in our business to maintain ongoing communication with you, to better understand your changing needs. We strive to earn your confidence and trust so that you know that your best interests are always being represented.
Why Trust Us?
What do we do differently than every other insurance agency? Consider this an invitation to get to know us…
Exceptional Employees
We believe we are an exceptional team of protection specialists that work hard to do things the right way, to educate our clients on insurance, and make the experience effortless.
New Experiences
Our team believes that the modern insurance customer leverages social media and other digital marketing resources prior to making a decision. We believe in providing educational content and engaging with our customers through social media and our website.
Encouraging Tech Enthusiasm
We encourage you to speak with our team who can show you how we use screen sharing, digital signatures, and video messaging.
Innovative Approaches
We will prove our innovative approaches to obtain the proper coverage’s for you, your family, your business.
We are dedicated to our clients and are focused on treating you as a person, not an insurance policy.
We at Schumacher, promise this to you, our clients and ask that if we fail to meet our promise, you let us know!
Customer Ratings & Reviews
“We have been using Schumacher for years for personal and business. Always amazing service, fast response, and a dedicated team of people that are awesome. Would never go anywhere else!”
– Jaime Restrepo
“Truly an A+ team over at Schumacher. I worked with Phil and Rich to help get us a commercial auto loan and I couldn’t have been more impressed with how gracious and knowledgeable they were, especially as an out-of-state customer. They got us an excellent price, were always willing to make any adjustments, and always had a quick response. Thank you!!”
– Michelle Haddad
“I have been a client with Schumacher Insurance for the past 5 years. I contacted the office to inquire about switching insurance auto and homeowners insurance to reduce my payments. I spoke with agent Maria who was extremely thorough and attentive. She was able to get me new policies which allowed me to save a couple hundred a year. I highly recommend.”
– Louis Christopher
“I’ve been doing business with Schumacher Insurance for over 20 years. My interactions with your agents have always been positive and upbeat each and every time. Maria was excellent…she addressed my latest issues in typical Schumacher fashion…courteously, timely and professionally. It would be a better world if more companies emulated your business model.”
– Doug VanHorn
How We Are Different
Listed below are several of the qualities that make our agency unique. Without these, most agencies are unable to fully protect their customers.
Located in West Caldwell, NJ
Our Address:
Hours of Operation:
Mon. – Fri. 9am – 5pm